I read most of the current
New York magazine article on children's self-esteem. It's about how praising children's intelligence actually makes them lazy and unwilling to try things at which they might fail, whereas children praised for their effort work harder and do better.
(By the way, after reading that summary sentence, you can skip the article. I was about 3,000 words into it when I realized it was just repeating that thought ad nauseum.)
I only read the article because I hate children, and know that the self-esteem nonsense has been creating monsters out of them for decades. If you've ridden public transit, surely you've seen it too: the stupid (and/or poor) kids scream endlessly about how great they are when they can't even form coherent sentences, arguing over their inherent perfection. The smarter (and/or richer) kids air their unearned entitlement whenever possible, spouting banal nonsense to each other (as opposed to
at each other like the poor kids), then perking up and throwing around statistics when impressible adults are around.
Aside: I also believe that the basic wrongness of hip-hop music is due to self-esteem training that began in the 1970's and 80's. The person doing the heavy lifting is the anonymous guy making the beats, who is rarely also the person talking over them. The one rapping about how great he is is usually unoriginal and untalented and learned the value of high self-esteem in the public school system. It's not that all rappers are without artistic merit, but almost anyone could have a hit album if Dr. Dre, Jay-Z, or the Neptunes were making the beats and producing it.
But back to my story- after all, what is blogging if not talking about oneself incessantly, like rappers of the internet- I realized that I was a test case for the praising intelligence versus praising effort.
I always got straight A's in everything until college. My brother was a B and C student. I'd bring home a report card and it would always be the same old thing, but if my brother got a B+ in something then they'd fall over themselves and we'd all go out for sundaes at Friendly's to celebrate. I think there was some reward system where we'd get 20 bucks or some portion of it for good grades, and they'd fluff up my brother's portion to encourage him, whereas to me they mustered all the enthusiasm of paying taxes.
But here's the real rub: My parents once told me when I was in 7th grade or so that they thought my brother was actually more intelligent, and I was not as smart but just worked harder. So rather than praise me for good grades they insulted me. (Note: is it any wonder I hated my parents?) This didn't result in me throwing myself off a bridge, but it drove me to try harder and get smarter and further prove that my parents are stupid hicks.
In the end though, my brother developed a work ethic in college and is the married one with a couple of houses whereas I stew in adolescent squalor. But I do work really hard at it.
Labels: bitterness, poverty, ranting, squalor