I've been to Rye twice so far, and I'll definitely be back. The trick is going at happy hour and grabbing a booth, because from what I understand, that's the only chance you'll have of getting one. The venue is pretty and chic, but let's get to the important part: the drinks.
The drink menu is divided into Classics and House Specials, with a couple bonus drinks that are the result of a monthly bartending competition. The Classics are generally drinks made with (surprise!) rye, and include a Rye Manhattan, Sazerac, a Daquiri, Dark and Stormy, and a Caipirinha.
The Rye Manhattan and Sazerac are both phenomenal. Start with the Manhattan though, as the other drink takes a warmed-up palette. I shouldn't write too much about these drinks as I'm going to do so for a pair of pieces in the Bay Guardian, but let me tell you this: small batch bourbon is getting all the attention lately, but the way they mix this stuff makes that look like starter booze. I last had the Manhattan about two months ago and I can still taste it. The trick to the Sazerac is letting the ice melt a minute before charging through it, as that helps separate the compact flavors in the rye and bitters.
The Dark and Stormy is the only drink I tried in this bar that didn't impress me. You couldn't really taste the rum distinct from the complex carbonated flavor of the ginger beer. Not bad at all, but not worth bothering with so many other delicious options.
On the House Specials list are a cosmopolitan (under a different name), the Blackberry Bramble (a vodka drink), the Basil Gimlet, and Apple Bomb, and the Golden Rye Fizz. The Fizz is made with rye, fresh clementine, Advocaat, sugar, and lemon. It tastes like a mild Orange Julius with a rye back. Good.
Finally, the special drinks. Rye hosts a monthly competition where they pick a liquor and bartenders can compete to invent a drink with it. If they win, it goes on Rye's menu. They have two on the menu currently (the bar hasn't been open that long) but the one that interested me was The Flash. It's made with fresh cucumber and kiwi with gin and I think a touch of lemon, and before I'd even read it at the end of the drink's description, I'd already guessed it was created by Carlos from Range. I think that says a lot about the caliber and style of Carlos' drinks, and also that I'm a huge drunk to have been able to pick that out.
The drink does not disappoint. It's fresh and crisp (as a cucumber, as they say) and it's the kind of drink that speaks, "Let's put on our polo whites and have a cocktail down by the croquet court." That's totally my look for Summer of 'Six.
Rye gets a very high recommendation from me, and remember to get there early.